
It doesn't get much better than this! (2009-07-02)
This brief review applies to the BluRay release. Excellent. Many others have already given detailed reviews of the movie itself, it's historical significance, plot synopsis, and critical remarks regarding the performances. But if you remember and have a fondness for the picture, this BluRay presentation hits the mark. The transfer and blending of the three film strips is almost flawless and you rarely notice the vertical separations. To fully realize the quality of this edition, you need to project the image onto an eight-foot wide screen or better and sit about six feet away. Add full multi-channel sound and you have an experience to enjoy. However, at the price it has dropped to recently, it's well worth it for the approximately 90 minute documentary on the development of CINERAMA. Warner Home Video and Amazon delivered on this one! Highly recommended.
Favorite Blu-Ray of 08, Favorite Western of 63 (2009-06-25)
Full Widescreen CINERAMA version and Smilebox (Simulated Cinerama version made by a Pro) version gives you three 35mm prints to make a 105mm image for your BluRay image and a multiTrack recording for your 5.1. Outside of Blade Runner, Batman Returns this is thE BD Disc!
Brings back great memories (2009-06-24)
I am old enough to remember seeing this movie in cinerama in downtown Chicago. It was wonderful, but you could see the seams. The sound was great.
I have seen it on vhs and dvd. Very disappointing.
But now, in blue ray and on a 2.35 54 x 129 inch screen, wow wow. Colors and sharpness are spectacular. Also, they have managed to almost eliminate the seams where the screens met.
I cannot decide which version they provide you with to watch. The standard version even on a 2.35 screeen gives you black bars. Using the curved version you just get a strange scalloped part at the top and bottom.
The story works, not overly complicated. They have thrown most of MGM's stars into the movie. Great to hear Spencer Tracy do the narration.
I rented it first and then bought it.
Unsmiling box (2009-06-23)
Great movie, I bought the Blu-Ray version. The only flaw was the
"smilebox" nonsense, a lame attempt to simulate the original Cinerama
effect. This was truly obnoxious. Please, next time think about creating
a version WITH and another WITHOUT this excessively cute and stunningly
useless stupid pet trick. I will happily dump my copy in the trash when
I find the correct undamaged Blu-ray version.
BluRay Release -- an epic in proportion (2009-06-10)
HTWWW Blu-Ray release is definitely a MUST-HAVE for all collectors who enjoy motion picture epics. I remember watching this movie in its original 3 projection panels and mesmerized by the larger-than-life moving images and surround-sound. Watching it again in Blu-Ray format, especially the SHOWBOX version, really does more than justice to the original intent of the movie producers. I also followed its various stages of releases from a dismal VHS tape to laserdisc and DVD formats. And being a HTWWW avid fan, nothing gives me the plesasure of reliving the magnificence and grandeur of this original celluloid masterpiece right in my living room...thru the magic of Blu-Ray.